View high resolution
ComicsAlliance Reviews ‘The Dark Knight’ (2008), Part Three
David: Welcome back to Cinematic Batmanology, for part three (!) of our look at Christopher and Jonathan Nolan’s The Dark Knight. When we last left the movie (part one, part two), Jim Gordon had seemingly died in the line of duty protecting the Mayor from the Joker at former Commissioner Loeb’s funeral, and this left Batman really pissed off. Harvey Dent had also absconded with one of the Joker’s henchmen from the scene of the crime. That henchman was wearing a nametag with the name Rachel Dawes, signaling her as the next to die.
Chris: In other words, things were pretty grim, even by Gotham City standards. And that’s saying something.
Chris: We didn’t really talk about Eric Roberts much in the earlier scenes, but he’s seriously great in this. Through all of his interactions with Dent and the Joker, he’s able to project this amazing smugness, and the scene in the nightclub really underscores that. I love that he’s sitting there with this goofy half-smile as he listens to house music.
David: “We can’t hear each other talk!” “What makes you think I want to hear you talk?” He’s an absolute douchebag to the girl he’s with, and it really underscores just how cocky he is with his mob influence.
Chris: Exactly, and he sells that cockiness really, really well. He’s a guy who is just flat-out not afraid of Batman. For now, anyway.
David: After working out his aggression on a bunch of thugs in a nightclub and grabbing Maroni, we cut to Rachel Dawes in the Major Crimes Unit, when Harvey Dent calls her to tell her she’s been tagged as the next victim and that MCU isn’t safe. Somewhat to Dent’s dismay, she says the safest place in Gotham right now is Bruce Wayne’s penthouse, and goes there.
Chris: That’s another great example of how sharp this script is. This is a super-tense scene with a huge threat hanging over Rachel, and we still get the comedy of Dent’s absolute disbelief that Bruce is trustworthy, or that he’s even remotely capable of keeping Rachel safe. Apparently, he still has no idea who choked him out at the fundraiser.
David: We then go back to Batman and Maroni, and Batman kicks off his interrogation by dropping him from a balcony just high enough to break his legs but not kill him. What’s great is that Maroni recognizes this and calls him on it, and Batman just goes “I’m counting on it” and drops him. I really have to wonder how they filmed this, since it really does look like Eric Roberts drops like five stories and breaks his ankles. I guess there’s a cut right between him falling and landing, so they could have used a harness or a doll.
Chris: Roberts does this great little immediate shift right after he drops where he starts spilling what he knows about the Joker, but it only lasts a second before he’s able to compose himself. Even being dropped and breaking his legs just reinforces what he knows about Batman: That Batman won’t kill him. So you get this great moment of Batman being just as ruthless as he can be within the moral structure set up by the first film, and it just does not work when it’s put up against what the Joker’s doing.
David: Batman asks Maroni where the Joker is, and Maroni says he has no damn idea. Batman continues to completely misunderstand the Joker by asking if he has any friends. Maroni points out that nobody’s going to turn on the Joker, since they know Batman won’t kill them or their family, while the Joker truly has no moral limits. At this point, Batman’s don’t-kill limitation is being tested like never before for him.
Chris: It’s this great bit of irony. Even the criminals now feel safer around Batman than they do around the Joker.
Andy: Batman’s interrogation of Maroni addresses something that you have to ignore in order to enjoy the comics after so many years, which is that eventually the criminals of Gotham will realize that the Batman will never murder them, but the Joker — and maybe even the cops — will. In a finite story like The Dark Knight, it’s a powerful moment and a turning point in Bruce’s mission. The Plan is no longer working, and if Maroni can figure it out, so can the Joker.
Read more at ComicsAlliance.




